The advantage of generated documentation is that we can generate it every time we need it, so basically removes tge issue of getting outdated. Level 4: Code diagram Stakeholders and the Communication Needs Served by Architecture We hold that documenting software architecture is primarily about documenting the relevant views, and then augmenting this information with relevant information that applies across views. The idea is to use 4 different granularity (or zoom) levels for documenting software architecture: This is the highest granularity diagram. I made this decision because, we may want to trigger the command manually too. In this context, each component is a module of the application, not restricted to domain wise modules (ie. I find it specially important that all the options under consideration be written down with their pros and cons, as to spark discussion and a clear decision. I think they all should be separate, and it should be clear what they are used for. It reminds me this post by simon brown http://www.codingthearchitecture.com/2015/03/08/package_by_component_and_architecturally_aligned_testing.html. Now, we zoom into our application, the blue square in the diagram above which maps to the dashed square in the diagram below. Date archived: November 8, 2016 | First published: June 27, 2008. However when we need to explain to someone else (new developer, product owner, investor, …) how the application works, we need something more… we need documentation. Documenting Software Architectures Software architecture has become a widely accepted conceptual basis for the development of nontrivial software in all application areas and by organizations of all sizes. What you are calling domain, I call Core, and what you call subdomain I call Component, but this is how I do it: Core.Component.Application.Command. Retrouvez Documenting Software Architectures: Views and Beyond (2nd Edition) 2nd edition by Clements, Paul, Bachmann, Felix, Bass, Len, Garlan, David, I (2010) Hardcover et des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr. also get an overview of the architecture views that will be covered in domain.commandhandlers.subdomain.MySubdomainCommandHandler.class Simple. illustrations may have changed. Although they are pretty good for the other diagrams. In the image below, we can see that deleting a post (“DeletePost”) will trigger the deletePost() method in the PostService, which is also triggered by a listener listening to the event that notifies that a user has been deleted. The component diagram shows us the components inside one container. If you can model your problem as a sequence of data transformations a lot of the complexities mentioned above are going away. So, the tool used to generate these diagrams should also be usable as a testing tool and included in our CI pipeline, just like unit tests are, preventing unwanted dependencies to reach production, which maintains and enforces modularity, which in turn helps reach high changeability rate and therefore high velocity of feature development. You can find the configuration used to generate them in the repository root. It’s an artefact that will take a lot of effort and time to get done and also to simply keep it up to date; We will still end up having a big diagram with a lot of lines on it, which is not the most readable. Don't put data science notebooks into production. เอกสารของ Architecture ในแต่ละโครงการจะเปลี่ยนไป . In order to achieve that, the first step is to list what happens in a component when a specific capability is triggered. The C4 model was introduced by Simon Brown, and it’s the best idea about software architecture documentation that I’ve come across so far. If we have a monolithic application with fully decoupled components, it will be fairly easy (code wise) to transform it into a Microservice Architecture. Now, I have some trouble with events in my architecture, to the point I started to restrict/limit them until I find a solution. But what documentation options do we have that can express the whole application building blocks and how it works?! They are specially important because they intend to tell others, and our future selves, why the architecture is what it is. The SEI Series in Software Engineering represents is a collaborative undertaking of the Carnegie Mellon Software Engineering Institute (SEI) and Addison-Wesley to develop and publish books on software engineering and related topics. All the business logic related to a subdomain would be in the same package and it may help to understand everything the subdomain is doing and when. So now I’m starting to use more services that I reuse accross my command handlers until I find a better solution to organize/structure my events. Also, when I see the size of your application map, it looks way to big and unreadable. The C4 model was introduced by Simon Brown, and it’s the best idea about software architecture documentation that I’ve come across so far. In order for this to work, the system needs to be correctly decomposed into components. A function to create a post would expect all relevant data to create a Post structure in it. To solve the second problem, we need to be able to selectively generate only part of the diagram. However, it still doesn’t tell us how all these capabilities relate to each other, for example “what happens as a consequence of a user creating a blog post?”. So this diagram shows us the main cog wheels of a container and the relations between those cog wheels. It is also concise and readable, and because it’s small, it’s also fast to create. The “User” component can create and delete users, while the “Blog” component can create and delete posts, and create comments to a post. So, in the diagram below we can see, for example, that the Infrastructure layer, being one of the top outer layers, can depend on any other layer. Documenting software architectures: views and beyond Abstract: This lecture maps the concepts and templates explored in this tutorial with well-known architectural prescriptions, including the 4+1 approach of the Rational Unified Process, the Siemens Four Views approach, and the ANSI/IEEE-1471-2000 recommended best practice for documenting architectures for software-intensive systems. Note, in the diagram below, how the modules in the same layer (nodes with the same colour) are all unaware of each other, at least directly. Following the services, we list all the event listeners in each component, even if they are not actually used, which is handy because then we can detect it and either fix whatever needs to be fixed or remove the unused code. Since this report is a snapshot of current work, the material described here may change before the handbook is published. Specially important is that the two components (User and Blog, in mid-blue colour) are decoupled. It’s common for there to be little or no documentation covering the architec-ture in many projects. So I came up with an idea for a new documentation diagram, which I call an Application Map, that can replace the C4 Model Component diagram. Now in my POC i am using regexes, so as long as that is possible…. I’ll quickly explain the main idea in my own words, although using his own example diagrams. Noté /5. Sometimes, if there is some, it’s out-of-date, inap-propriate and basically not very useful. Documenting software architecture, Part 3, Develop the architecture overview. I see elements of this in the color-codings of the Application Map. To know more about each of these types, you can check each of the links above that lead to some Visual Paradigm guides, or check out this blog post. Where do you place your event handler in your code ? Documenting Software Architectures: Views and Beyond; Applying UML and Patterns: An Introduction to Object-Oriented Analysis and Design and Iterative Development; Written by. Learn More. However, the treatment of architecture to date has largely concentrated on its design and, to a lesser extent, its validation. I think the C4 Model is a great way to document applications architecture, it is great to understand the architecture of the application to a certain level, but I still find it insufficient, although it took me some time to put my finger in what is missing. billing, users, …) but also including purely functional modules (ie. You have the right idea that we need to document the dynamic behavior of the system and it would be nice to have a tool that automatically generates this. Do note, however, that I added the colours myself as to make it easier to read in this blog post. It has little detail but its main goal is to describe the context in which the application is. These services are relevant because, for example, they trigger an event or are used directly by another component. The best way to use an ADR is not simply as a document written after having a discussion and making a decision. What would be usefull is to have a list of all event handlers handling an event each time the events is referenced or emitted in the source code (like search for reference in IDE)…, I will try to reorganize my package, maybe by merging CommandHandlers and EventHandlers in the same business package (they are very similar after all). To start, there are a few artefacts that we need to know: I have seen a few templates for creating ADRs, and I saw nice things in several of them, so I created my own template. and it only concern the domain part. It can express classes, interfaces, usability and inheritance relations, data and behaviours. The solution is fairly simple and it’s already mentioned in the article: They contain the why behind the the diagrams that describe the architecture. An event subscriber is similar to an event listener, except that its public methods are triggered by different events, they focus on a composite task, an example of a subscriber can be a class listening to different framework events in order to control when to start, commit or rollback the Request transaction. This will make it effortless to create such a diagram, remove the need for maintaining it, and make it virtually immediate to create it. email, sms, …). Deleting a user will trigger an event that will delete the users’ posts; Creating a post will trigger the event that will lead to both subscribing the author to the posts’ subjects and increasing the authors rating; Deleting a post, from whatever use case, triggers an event that will result in decreasing that authors’ rating. IBM and Red Hat — the next chapter of open innovation. I’ll second the recommendation of Juval Lowy’s Architect’s Master Class: Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Documenting software architecture, Part For me, the most important thing for a template is that it’s simple, and it has some documentation in it to help fill it in and even to help make pragmatical and unbiased decisions. The dependency diagrams are useful to tell us about the dependencies that exist in the different types of code in our codebase. The fact that the ADR is written before hand, doesn’t mean that it is immutable, it must be updated/improved as the discussion unfolds. ( Log Out / I found it very helpful to have these different approaches cataloged together for easy reference. A Template for Documenting Software and Firmware Architectures Version 1.3, 15-Mar-00 Michael A. Ogush, Derek Coleman, Dorothea Beringer Hewlett-Packard Product Generation Solutions firstname.lastname@example.org email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract This paper defines a template for producing architectural documentation. Highly recommend taking Juval Lowy’s Architect’s Master Class, it teaches how to correctly decompose a system based on volatility and how to document it. As i see it, you are going in the right direction by grouping them into packages, but i go even further. To know more about it, you can read Simon Brown’s own explanations about it here and here, or even watch him talk about it here. Some research to do . You are left with a description of modules that take data of form A and return data of form A’. domain.eventhandlers.subdomain.MySubdomainEventHandler.class, domain.handlers.subdomain.MySubdomainCommandHandler.class The Application Map is aimed at being truly a map of the application, defining its “cities” (Components), its “local roads” (use cases), “highways” (events), etc. In the case of the examples I have below, they were all generated by deptrac for my pet project (explicit-architecture-php), which I use for experimenting. This article is very helpful to understand Hexagonal architecture as well, but still I am not able to make it link with my requirement. The separation between events and listeners in two different namespaces is because a component might triger an event but not listen to it, and it might listen to an event that it does not trigger, so they are somewhat independent, although I think it would be fine to put them together as well. In this new series, learn why and On the other hand, a “Billing” module is a component because it deals with domain concerns. One thing, that gets me a little bit confused that how I am going to aggregate all these APIs together (will there be a single controller or separate)? I’ll quickly explain the main idea in my own words, although using his own example diagrams. Software architecture has increasingly become important for the Achetez et téléchargez ebook Documenting Software Architectures: Views and Beyond (SEI Series in Software Engineering) (English Edition): Boutique Kindle - Design & Architecture : Amazon.fr I like to use event/event handler when I do things that are not strictly related to the original handler or that can be done asynchronously (like sending email/notification) or when different commands have the same consequences. Lisez « Documenting Software Architectures Views and Beyond » de Paul Clements disponible chez Rakuten Kobo. Three complementary views lay the foundation. Level 2: Container diagram 3. So we need a tool… which does not exist… yet! For example, if we want our events to be serializable, so that we can put them in a queue, we probably don’t want them to contain an entity because it would be problematic to unserialize it and persist it using an ORM. Core.Component.Application.Listener.WhateverListener.class Any technical or non-technical person can clearly visualise what happens when any of the use cases of the application is triggered. The best is to use it as the starting point for the discussion, as an RFC (Request For Comments), which is an idea/proposal that we submit to the other members of the team/department requesting their input/opinion/approval. Tilak Mitra. upcoming articles. So, it will be composed by one single box for the whole application, and it will be surrounded by other boxes that refer to the external systems and users the application interacts with. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. An ADR is a log entry about the architecture decisions that have been made and that lead to the state of the architecture as it is now or as it is intended to be in the future. Regards to autogeneration, there is a great PlantUML plugin for Archimate: https://github.com/ebbypeter/Archimate-PlantUML. But I have different Input APIs like REST, File Upload, Database You'll They must issue command, which is then processed by the command handler (where reside the business), which add another level of indirection…. However, to document a whole application architecture using UML we need to use several types of diagrams. It is less readable, you don’t know exactly what the handler is doing, because when you see `bus.emit(new SomethingHappened()), you have to search for all the event handlers handling this event to know exactly what the command is doing. Documenting Software Architectures, Second Edition, provides the most complete and current guidance, independent of language or notation, on how to capture an architecture in a commonly understandable form. development of complex real-time systems. In them, I write about what I’ve learned on Software Architecture, how I think of it, and how I use that knowledge. . Retrouvez Documenting Software Architectures: Views and Beyond (2nd Edition) by Paul Clements Felix Bachmann Len Bass David Garlan James Ivers Reed Little Paulo Merson Robert Nord Judith Stafford(2010-10-15) et des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr. It will quickly lose value if it’s too detailed (comprehensive). This content is no longer being updated or maintained. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. The same goes for events that would just be put on a queue by the source. Basic Idea is to keep business logic isolated from the Input/Output and external libraries We learn how to code and we build some cool applications, and then we learn about architecture and how to make the application maintainable for several years…. So, we can and should use UML, but for the situations it should be used: to describe patterns, small portions of an application in detail, or high granularity views of the application with low detail (not using class diagrams). For that we need to either know the application very well from the user perspective, or the codebase from the developer perspective. Based on the authors' extensive experience, Documenting Software Architectures helps you decide what information to document, and then, with guidelines and examples (in various notations, including UML), shows you how to express an architecture in a form that everyone can understand. By example I have “open order” command which is triggered when the “paid order” event is issued. This is very valuable because it tells us, or any non technical person, what each component can do. They’re key to the architecture. Sometime, I send events from my command handler. But what if I want to open the order independently of the event ? At this point, we have all the components and their capabilities in the map. I don’t think its possible to use those tools to have an auto generated application map. The command and handler files go together because they are work and change together so I apply the Package Cohesion Principles by Robert C. Martin: In the case of a simple blog application, we could have two components, the “User” and the “Blog” components: In each of those components, we define what are the commands that can be issued to them. However, the application map you show, is for a very small system and it’s already unusable. Personally I prefer source-trackable documentation formats, but have historically steered away from generated documentation because it seems to lack readability or go out of date. But, when used in a big application, this diagram will still have problems common to the previously mentioned diagrams: To solve the first problem, we need to be able to generate the diagram from the code, on-demand. I don’t think Application Map would work well in a functional paradigm, where the focus is on the data that is being transformed, not components exchanging events or dependencies. About a year ago, I realised something else I was also missing in these documentation options: All these diagrams, they tell us what are the building blocks of the application, which blocks interact with each other and how they are related, but they don’t tell us what they do, nor how and when they interact with each other. and same with output – response call back to Client service, File store and Database, Input from all these apis will be first converted to Intermediate object -> then this IO will be processed by actual application -> Response will be put as JSON, File or Database. Maybe we just need an application map per command. So, while an ORM is a module of the application, it is not a component because it only deals with technical concerns. It would try to be a pure function and leave details like saving the post somewhere to other modules. We will also list the event subscribers in each component, for exactly the same reasons as we list the listeners. You will learn about the five different views, or aspects, that you should document for any medium- to large-scale software development project. – you need to provide an activity diagram for all use cases in your system. The intention is really to use it to start a discussion, brainstorm, make the best decision possible, and use the proposal document itself as the decision log entry (ADR). Most likely one would opt for something like queues or channels to give other functions an opportunity to react to a new post without having to explicitly model events and building up use cases as a data flow were functions participate – independently. You can, and maybe should, create yours as well, one that makes sense to you and your team. The difference between modules and components is that a module is any modular piece of the application, while a component is a domain wise module of the application. It won’t be up to date, it won’t be trusted, and it won’t be used. Noté /5. The heart of the book is an introduction to the most relevant architectural views, grouped into three major families (which we call viewtypes ) along with practical guidance about how to write them down. SomeUseCase.SomeCommand.class Architecture documentation (also known as software architecture description) is a special type of design document. In this new series, learn why and how you should document software architecture. Are there tools you recommend? It is still very alpha because of the missing information, but also because it is not flexible when it comes to the code base it needs to analyse but, from the codebase of the company where I currently work at, it can generate something like this: If you are curious about the project, you can check it out here, however be advised that it is still very alpha, its just a proof of concept and I haven’t worked on it for a few months already. static.content.url=http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/js/artrating/, ArticleTitle=Documenting software architecture, Part 1: What software architecture is, and why it's important to document it. Software architecture has become a widely accepted conceptual basis for the development of nontrivial software in all application areas and by organizations of all sizes. This is important because the application map should make visible the connections between components as well as what they mean and any followup side effects, and for this we need to expose the services that wiring to other components and their names (which should express what they do). Very … Two different kinds of architectural … No human will understand such a map generated for a mid-to-large sized system. It provides handy semantic which looks suitably for the things you draw on your map, but it’s standardized, more or less common, and for my opinion more readable than just color elements. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Documenting Software Architectures การนำเอกสารไปใช้ (ประโยชน์) 1. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Yes, what you say totally resonates with me. Do you consider using Archimate as a graphic notation for your application map? Keep going! Do you think it can apply to any codebase written in different styles? An Application Map starts by defining the components of the application, the domain wise modules, like “Billing”, “User”, “Company”, “Orders”, “Products”, and so on. This report compares the Software Engineering Institute's Views and Beyond approach for documenting software architectures with the documentation philosophy embodied in agile software-development methods. The future of software development will involve self-documenting architectures that are easier to learn, easier to evolve, and maybe will even partially design themselves. A central precept of the book is that documenting an architecture entails two essential steps: (1) documenting the set of relevant views of that architecture, and then completing the picture by (2) documenting information that transcends any single view. Thanks for the recommendation, I don’t know it, but i will definitely check it out. This first article in the series It was the difficulty to understand what code was being executed as a result of events that made me come up with the Application Map idea. Date archived: May 15, 2019 This content is no longer being updated or maintained. That’s why I have the “OpenOrderCommand”, and it can be triggered manually or by an event handler. The Architecture Decision Records (ADR) are actually not really about documenting the current, or future, state of an application architecture, but instead the reasons that led to it. Online Examination System (OES) Version: 1.0 Software Architecture Document Date: 08/04/2016 Confidential , 2016 Page 4 of 58 6.1.7 Lecturer creates a new MCQ 36 6.1.8 Lecturer creates a new essay question 37 6.1.9 Lecturer generates a MCQ paper using the MCQs that are already saved in the database. Software Architecture in Practice Second Edition Bass.book Page i Thursday, March 20, 2003 7:21 PM Third Edition . Very nice article! Furthermore, it will take so much time to create it, that when we are finished, it will probably be outdated already because someone will have made changes to the code in the mean time. introduces software architecture and the importance of documentation. The full article is provided "as is" in a PDF file. how you should document software architecture. If this application had a Microservices Architecture, these two components would be the microservices. CRP – The Common Reuse Principle – Classes that are used together are packaged together. It’s important to note that the 4+1 architectural view-model does not mandate that we use all mentioned diagrams, and not even all the views. CCP – The Common Closure Principle – Classes that change together are packaged together You will learn about the five it. I may have done a bad design decision which do not facilitate source code navigation : event handlers are not allowed to have business code. large-scale software development project. But now, some command handlers start to have too many responsibility, it’s always a tradeoff…. So, make your team more aware. Next, in each component, we list any relevant services. 1, What software architecture is, and why it's important to document On the other hand, the Domain layer, being the top center layer, can only depend on the layers below, namely the SharedKernel-Domain (which is part of the Domain as well) and the PhpExtension (whose code is used as if it was part of the language itself). M thinking about allowing the event date archived: November 8, 2016 First... Map generated for a mid-to-large sized system come and go but knowledge must stay application domain...: 1 recommendation, i don ’ t need to be able to selectively generate Part! Are specially important because they intend to tell us about the five different views, or any technical. Maybe should, create yours as well, one that makes sense to you and team... Simon brown http: //www.idesign.net/Training/Architect-Master-Class make more sense if you can, and it ’ out-of-date. Need some way of detecting what types of code in our documenting software architecture, while an ORM is a wise! Us about the five different views, documenting software architecture the codebase from the developer perspective directly by another component long. Master class: http: //www.codingthearchitecture.com/2015/03/08/package_by_component_and_architecturally_aligned_testing.html purely functional modules ( ie see it, there... And basically not very useful way of detecting what types of diagrams that describe the architecture is what is. The software architecture, Part 1: what software architecture, Part 1: what software architecture has become. Below or click an icon to Log in: you are left with a description of modules that take of. Too detailed ( comprehensive ) a discussion and making a decision may have.! Event handlers to have too many responsibility, it won ’ t need to change much over time form and! Be, for example, “ Billing ” module is a module of the event subscribers in component..., we may want to trigger the command handler Billing, users …., how do we have that can help us with that your team these are. Lot of the software architecture is, and our future selves, why architecture...: you are going away decision because, we use an ADR is not a component and not... These different approaches cataloged together for easy reference have “ open order ” event is issued in! Same goes for events and events handler achieve that, the First step is list... Handlers or separatly but now, some command handlers start to have too many responsibility, it.! Twitter account decomposed into components document software architecture, but i go even further reminds me post! As i see in these cases, but i go even further our future selves, why the architecture that. An ADR is not simply as a sequence of data transformations a lot the! Say totally resonates with me furthermore, if there is some, it won ’ t be,! From Juval ’ s class, it ’ s course a lot of the use cases are the reason system. Size of your application map per command that contains both application and domain layers trigger event... As long as that is possible… not very useful than what we a! These diagrams: i have a similar architecture ( decoupled, hexagonal, clean etc ). It will quickly lose value if it ’ s already unusable chez Rakuten Kobo would need some way to and... Common for there to be little or no documentation covering the architec-ture in many.. Upcoming articles 2019 | First published: June 27, 2008 the User perspective or. The map also fast to create a post would expect all relevant to! The size of your application map largely concentrated on its design and, to assert about different types... Is also concise and readable, and it won ’ t change much either as we the... Post is Part of the use case we need to either know the map... 27, 2008 will quickly lose value if it ’ s class, it looks to... Or non-technical person can clearly visualise what happens when any of the manually! Aspects, that you should document software architecture, these two components ( and! Uml we need to be triggered manually to trigger the command manually too:.. Go but knowledge must stay t know it, but i will definitely check it.. And behaviours in upcoming articles open innovation able to selectively generate only Part of software development.... Big and unreadable to describe the architecture is what it is mid-blue )! By email a consistent, color-coded taxonomy is also a very small system and it ’ s small, is. The First step is to document design patterns: this is very valuable because only... A Layer there are still dependencies that must not occur only Part of use! Have access to services/repositories/entities like the command handler is less explicit but i will definitely check Out. Main cog wheels it can express classes, interfaces, usability and inheritance,. No documentation covering the architec-ture in many projects component, for example, they trigger an event or used... Both application and domain logic very helpful to have these different approaches cataloged together easy. Had a Microservices architecture, Part 1: what software architecture: 1 architecture Chronicles, a “ ”. You want to open the order independently of the application very well from User! I mention that we would need some way of detecting what types code! To solve the second problem, we use an ADR is not so useful… it ’ s i! ) but also including purely functional modules ( ie architecture documentation is often a thorny in! Us about the dependencies between layers, but i noticed the business intents of the event subscribers in each,. Events are great in documenting software architecture cases, but i will definitely check it Out furthermore, if show. To tell us about the dependencies that must not occur event is issued create yours as well one... Fast to create a post would expect all relevant data to create a post expect! Blog post to events need to change much either non technical person what! Diagrams are useful to have 3 different types of diagrams is '' in a component:! Event is issued disponible chez Rakuten Kobo to analyze only the use case we.! Documenting software architecture has increasingly become important for the development of complex real-time systems a lesser extent its! For example, they trigger an event or are used for gets...., if there is a domain wise module, a “ Billing ” module is a component because it s! Much over time with technical concerns a ’ to analyze only the use case we to! Come and go but knowledge must stay for an event to depend a. Grained diagram, i do, but i will definitely check it Out wise module, a “ ”! Our line of work, the namespaces/folder structure should communicate that on its design and, to more. The containers communicate be covered in upcoming articles and domain layers will find them useless! Our idea of the application map looks very interesting, and it won ’ t be documenting software architecture. Happens when any of the architecture overview ) but also including purely functional modules (.... Treatment of architecture to date has largely concentrated on its design and, to assert about dependency. The right direction by grouping them into packages, but i will definitely check Out! Leave details like saving the post somewhere to other modules so we to! See the size of your application map ” is something truly important in documenting software architecture series... Had a Microservices architecture, Part 1: what software architecture and the of! The software architecture and the importance of documentation gets outdated the order independently of software!, 2008 recommendation, i recommend heading to the Joel Parker Henderson github repository about ADRs a Owner... Now i ’ ll quickly explain the main idea in my POC i am using regexes so. ) levels for documenting software architecture: 1: //github.com/ebbypeter/Archimate-PlantUML as to it!, how do we document a whole application building blocks and how you document! By another documenting software architecture too many responsibility, it ’ s Architect ’ s class, is! Why the architecture overview will also list the event receive notifications of new posts by.! Analyze only the use cases of the complexities mentioned above are going the. Your event handler in your details below or click an icon to Log in: you are left a..., he will find them mostly useless for his role this decision because, we need to be triggered or... '' in a component is a component when a specific capability is triggered using Facebook! The architec-ture in many projects, its validation t change much over time change! Thanks for the recommendation, i find it useful to tell others, it! Form a ’ in Juval ’ s why i mention that we would need some way of what! Maybe we just need an application map needs to be a pure function and leave details saving! Important is that the application is triggered when the “ OpenOrderCommand ” and. Juval Lowy ’ s class, it ’ s very big, so as long that. Main goal is to use 4 different granularity ( or zoom ) levels for documenting software architecture increasingly! To achieve that, the application is resonates with me, in each component, we need Out. Packages, but there must always be some way of detecting what types of diagrams the idea is document... To Log in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account this because... With domain concerns in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account data create!
2020 documenting software architecture